I agree that the winter frequency has to do with the increased difficulty of travel, and the incrase in fatigue per failed test, has to do with the encumbrance of the gear, but my suggestion is to only apply the increase when it is actually needed i.e. In the winter season.Glorelendil wrote:??Indur Dawndeath wrote:But they dont have to wear the warm winter clothes, freeze at night or melt ice to get water, so no need to change the fatigue ratings. Just stick with RAW.
Cheers
Maybe we're understanding the meaning of the rules a little bit differently. I always took the encumbrance of the travel gear to simply mean the weight/bulkiness of traveling gear. So even if you've got those sweaters and wool blankets packed away for the future, you're still carrying them.
The frequency of the checks of the travel checks (every 3 days in winter, every 6 days in summer, etc.) has to do with being wet and cold, trudging through snow, etc.
Am I understanding the rules differently than others?
Equally there is no difference in fatigue per failed test from packing for a long trip and a short one...
A perfectly valid reason for the increase in fatigue could be that the consequence of a failed test is more dire in the winter season. If you fail to get a fire going in the winter or fail to find shelter, you could actually die!
Anyway my suggestion was only to keep it simple.