So, I'm thinking they should be about 1000 End, 10 hate, and 6D of Armor, with Parry of 10 or so...
And Attribute level 15. Attack does 15, Edge sauron, Injury 24; skill is 2d but NOT favored.
Stone Giant Rules ?
Re: Stone Giant Rules ?
When I read the HoME referred to the process of writing the Fellowship of the Rings, Chistropher Tolkien mentions that, in the beginning, the Ents where just a name that derivated from the old "Ettin", that is a Giant. The Ettenmoors where a place where giants could be found, and in the first drafts, what we now know as Ents where Evil Giants (nothing to do with trees in that phase).zedturtle wrote: Huh, the only reference I see is to Tree-men ("giants you might call them" says Sam); some sort of alusion to Ents/Entwives.
In the first writings, Gandalf was not held captive by Saruman in Orthanc (Saruman still didn't exist), but by a "Giant named Fangorn in the south", and therefore he couldn't help Frodo travel to Rivendell.
So, back to the topic, I think that Giants could exist. He didn't change the name of the Ettenmoors and it seems to come from the Ettin. But I agree that they could be used maybe better as a Journey Hazard than as a monster to battle.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: onestitchloose, Wbweather, Winterwolf and 5 guests