forums.cubicle7.co.uk
archive

Jon, if and when we meet I shall bribe you with the beverage of your choice.

Can't wait for this!

JRRT would I am sure have hated the PJ movies for missing the whole point. I enjoy them as what I always thought a D&D movie should be. That way I can keep from apoplexy at all the things that have drastically changed from Tolkien.

I do agree with his decision to move most of the exposition from the Council of Elrond to the beginning and show what happened. Filmed by the book that scene would have been a bunch of people sitting around a table listening to someone talk. As PJ said "It's a board meeting and you can't film board meetings. They are too boring."

I don't like leaving out Bombadil and the Mouth of Sauron.

DavetheLost wrote: I don't like leaving out Bombadil and the Mouth of Sauron.

The Mouth of Sauron is in the extended edition.

gatharion wrote:

DavetheLost wrote: I don't like leaving out Bombadil and the Mouth of Sauron.

The Mouth of Sauron is in the extended edition.

And gets his head chopped off.

Another Great PJ Improvementtm.

Rich H wrote:

gatharion wrote:

DavetheLost wrote: I don't like leaving out Bombadil and the Mouth of Sauron.

The Mouth of Sauron is in the extended edition.

And gets his head chopped off.

Another Great PJ Improvementtm.

http://youtu.be/o8vDfMRCgvU?list=PLVB91 ... gcoGu6CkVt_

'Oh my gosh, we've been following a lunatic!'

shipwreck wrote:http://youtu.be/o8vDfMRCgvU?list=PLVB91 ... gcoGu6CkVt_

'Oh my gosh, we've been following a lunatic!'

Jerry. Jerry. Jerry.

Brilliant.

I have to say nice system for magical treasure, very inventive. Though Gandalf, Thorin and crew got really lucky with the Treasure Rolls in the Troll Hoard.

Beran wrote:I have to say nice system for magical treasure, very inventive.

Indeed.

Beran wrote:Though Gandalf, Thorin and crew got really lucky with the Treasure Rolls in the Troll Hoard.

Perhaps stretching it too much?

I personally wish they were less randomly acquired - eg, needing the right result on a Feat Die when coming across a treasure hoard, followed by requiring varying degrees of success on a set of d6s. I can see me coming up with a set of house-rules to provide more narrative control to the GM and players.

Agreed.

Personally, I'd allow hoards to have more "rolls" per player, depending on their size and other attributes.