cuthalion wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 12:02 am
Wow, let's not bag on people for their spelling. No matter how lighthearted it's meant, that's like 5 separate people pointing out how the OP has misspelt words in their post to 1 person actually replying and being helpful. Nobody needs that.
Well said, fella, really not cool at all.
cuthalion wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 12:02 am
Lifstan, it's a good question. I think you're right to think twice about the Rohirrim. They are a much more martial culture, less 'developed' than Arnor/Gondor. Much more oral tradition--per Valerian--and see Horse Lords p. 8 "Songs of the Riders". They make me think of Saxons/Nordic cultures. Think of Eomer at the border of Fangorn, talking about how knowledge of the area has passed into fairy tale status.
I'd certainly go along with this. The Woodmen and Beornings would fall into this category too; sharing common and semi-recent heritage.
cuthalion wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 12:02 am
That said, there's probably a difference when it comes to rank/status. Is the character an elder? A marshal? Do they belong to a lineage? Do they own land? All those things would make it more likely for them to be literate.
I'd personally go with what best fits the requirements of adventure. I could see a landed noble more likely to be able to read and write but is that a necessity? Not sure it is until you get to the royalty; where there is a need for them to receive and interact with outsiders as well as being the ruler of their land and maintaining law and order by decree, etc. I'd therefore think about the role of each such person within society and decide if reading/writing is something that would greatly benefit them. If not, then I wouldn't bother. Also, if required a character could understand/recognise certain words in order to 'get by'; for example guard recognising the content of a merchant's documents/goods rather then being able to read books of lore, etc.
cuthalion wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 12:02 am
See also the table on p.15 of the Adventurer's Companion--or presumably somewhere in the Horse Lords supplement--which actually points to Sindarin being a possible secondary language, which surprised me, and that the language of Gondor (by which they mean the Common Tongue) is spoken in court since the crowning of Thengel King.
The Sindarin element does surprise although the language of Gondor is a good way to allow for ease of communication with outsiders for gaming purposes if not for anything else. Although, it being spoken in court is something to develop ideas from; I mean, how would some in court feel about a foreign language being spoken above theirs? I can see that and other elements as seeds to sow division if someone so wished...